Comparing Depression Treatments

In considering ECT vs ketamine treatments or talk therapy vs conventional antidepressants here is an abbreviated list of key considerations:

Talk Therapy

•Prices vary

•Easily Accessible from many sources

•Once a week for months or years

•Possibly covered by insurance

Traditional Antidepressants

•Slow acting, high rate of relapse after months and rebound with discontinuation

•Easily Accessible from many sources

•Prices vary

•Possibly covered by insurance depending on your insurance company

Electro-Convulsive Therapy (ECT)

•Side effects may include short term memory loss

•Have to be under general anesthesia

•Needs boosters for continued benefit

•Accessible from psychiatrists only

•Generally covered by insurance

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)

•Time-Consuming, daily treatments

•Possibly covered by insurance if you meet stringent criteria

•Accessible from psychiatrists

Intra-Nasal Ketamine Treatments (ketamine or esketamine)

•Easy to administer, but burns and has increased nausea

•Not as effective as IV Ketamine, limited research to date

•Possibly covered by insurance

•Patients are more likely to show addictive behaviors than with IV administration

•Appears to be free from lasting negative side effects

IV Ketamine Treatments

•Not yet covered by insurance

•Appears to be free from lasting negative side effects

•Immediate action

•Works well for around 75% of patients

•Works regardless of other treatments – even when other treatments do not

Deep Brain Stimulation

•Involves brain surgery and a permanently implanted device

Of course, this list isn’t exhaustive, and treatment considerations are highly dependent on a patient’s specific situation. You can use this list as a kind of cheat sheet, or roadmap, to frame the discussion.

Please click here for more information on how to treat depression and the best treatment options.

Author

Dr. Allison Wells, MD

You Might Also Enjoy...

Flowers on a Table - Lone Star Infusion

Mental Health Wellness for Quarantine

Helpful advice. Mental health wellness tips for quarantine.

Sleep is Important for Mental Health

Sleep and Mental Health

The quality of sleep is an important part of your mental health. Getting the right amount of sleep and getting good sleep may help with mood disorders, including depression and anxiety. There are some easy (and not so easy) ways to improve your sleep.

Figure 1. Time by maltreatment load interaction for QIDS-SR

New Research: More Good News for Treatment-Resistant Depression

New Research on Lone Star Infusion Treatments: The Impact of Childhood Maltreatment on Intravenous Ketamine Outcomes for Adult Patients with Treatment-Resistant Depression

Bipolar Disorder and Treatment Options

Bipolar disorder may be the least understood and the most stigmatized mood disorder. But there is hope. Treatments may help.

The Fight to Get Better: Recovering from Depression and Anxiety can be Difficult.

I frequently see this with my patients: Ketamine treatments are often effective for depression and anxiety, but getting better can still take work.

Childhood Trauma and Ketamine

Patients with high levels of childhood trauma are more difficult to treat, however ketamine can still effectively treat them and does so better than typical antidepressants.